Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie

ByNicole Harris
Jump to Recipe

sponsored post:

This Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie is an impressive and decadent game day dessert.  Delicious layers of brownies, vanilla ice cream, chocolate ice cream, Milky Way Bites and caramel will have your sports fans cheering!
ice cream pie from the side showing layers of brownie, white ice cream, brown ice cream and chopped candy bars, photo text: ice cream Milky Way brownie pie

This post may contain affiliate links. See my Disclosure Policy for more info. Follow WonkyWonderful on Pinterest to stay up to date on all of the new recipes!

Easy Ice Cream Cake

I have been wanting to create a dessert recipe that is over-indulgent and crazy delicious!  When I got the opportunity to do a post highlighting Mars Bites, I knew that day had come.  So I didn’t hold back on this one.  This pie has every amazing flavor that you could want:

Chocolate . . . Vanilla . . . Caramel . . . Milky Way . . . Yum!

This Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie is so hedonistic, it should be illegal!  It is a show stopper.  Okay, the guys aren’t really going to look away from the football game.  But on the commercial break they will surely be amazed, right before they begin to devour it!

Time to get started on the Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie!

brownie batter in bottom of round pan

This recipe involves multiple steps, but they are all simple.  Step One: Make the brownie layer. {recipe below}

white ice cream on top of cooked brownies in round pan

Step Two: Chill brownies then top with softened vanilla ice cream.

hand spreading white ice cream with spatula

Return springform pan to freezer until ice cream is firm.

Milky Way package next to cutting board with chopped Milky Way candy bars

Step Three: Chop your Milky Way Bites into delicious little chunks.

brown ice cream in round pan next to Milky Way package

Step Four: Spread a layer of softened chocolate ice cream on top of the vanilla layer.

chopped candy bar pieces in round pan next to Milky Way package

Step Five: Top with Milky Way Bites and return to freezer. Freeze overnight.

closeup of pie with brownie layer, vanilla ice cream and chocolate ice cream layers topped with candy bars

To release the springform, run a wash cloth under hot water and wipe along the outside of the springform pan.  Repeat 2-3 times then release the springform and carefully remove the sides.

This pie should be frozen solid, so get one of those football watching manly men to lend you a hand {and some muscle}.  The first slice is a little tricky.

Top each slice of Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie with a drizzle of store bought caramel topping . . . Touchdown!

slice of brownie ice cream pie drizzled with caramel

Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie ::: wonkywonderful.com ::: #GameDayBites #shop

Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie

Yield: 1
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 30 minutes

This Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie is an impressive and decadent game day dessert.  Delicious layers of brownies, vanilla ice cream, chocolate ice cream, Milky Way Bites and caramel will have your sports fans cheering!

Ingredients

Brownies

  • 1/2 Cup Unsweetened Cocoa
  • 2/3 Cup AP Flour
  • 1/4 tsp Baking Powder
  • 1/4 tsp Salt
  • 1/2 Cup Melted Butter, slightly cooled
  • 1 Cup Ultra Fine Sugar
  • 1 tsp Vanilla Paste or Extract
  • 2 Eggs

Ice Cream Pie

  • 28 oz Vanilla Ice Cream
  • 28 oz Chocolate Ice Cream
  • 2 Packages of Milky Way or Snickers Bites, 7 oz
  • 1 Jar Caramel Topping

Instructions

Brownies

  1. Preheat oven to 350°
  2. Using a fork or whisk; mix the cocoa, flour, baking powder and salt. Set aside.
  3. In a separate bowl; combine the melted butter, sugar, vanilla and eggs.
  4. Using a hand mixer; slowly add the dry ingredients to the wet. Mix until just smooth. (batter will be thick)
  5. Spread evenly into an extra greased 9 inch springform pan.
  6. Place springform on a cookie sheet and bake for 26-28 minutes or until a toothpick can be inserted and removed cleanly.
  7. Allow brownies to cool then transfer to the refrigerator or freezer until cold.

Ice Cream Pie

  1. Wipe the inside of the springform pan to remove any grease residue.
  2. Top brownie layer with softened vanilla ice cream.
  3. Return springform pan to freezer until ice cream is firm.
  4. Chop your Milky Way Bites into delicious little chunks.
  5. Spread a layer of softened chocolate ice cream on top of the vanilla layer.
  6. Top with Milky Way chunks and return to freezer. Freeze overnight.
  7. To release the springform, run a wash cloth under hot water and wipe along the outside of the springform pan. Repeat 2-3 times then release the springform and carefully remove the sides
  8. Slice and drizzle with caramel topping.
Nutrition Information
Yield 10 Serving Size 1
Amount Per Serving Calories 647Total Fat 31gSaturated Fat 19gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 10gCholesterol 125mgSodium 329mgCarbohydrates 84gFiber 3gSugar 69gProtein 10g

Nutritional information on WonkyWonderful is provided as a courtesy and is approximate only. We cannot guarantee the accuracy of the nutritional information given for any recipe on this site.

© Nicole Harris
Cuisine: American / Category: desserts
More Ice Cream Creations:
Honey Ricotta Ice Cream
Chocolate Cake Batter Ice Cream with Sprinkles
Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream {no machine needed}

Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie pinnable photo collage with recipe title text

3

Leave a Reply to Consuelo @ Honey & Figs Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

43 Comments

    1. Thanks Becca! It tastes positively heavenly too. Have a fantastic weekend!

      Reply

  4. I just love ice cream cakes.. ice cream pies… Milky ways… so yeah, in case you didn’t figure it out yet, this recipe is freaking AMAZING! I want this for my birthday cake! (that’s not till January but still)

    Reply

    1. lol, I’m so glad you like it Kammie! It will make an amazing birthday cake!

      Reply

  9. Oh my goodness, what an amazingly delicious looking dessert!!!! I LOVE ice-cream pies, and this one looks to die for!!

    Reply

  11. Oh, wow! I wish that I found this recipe sooner! This would have been exactly the type of ice cream cake I’d love to eat on my b-day (which is tomorrow)! Definitely trying this recipe ASAP.

    Reply

    1. Thanks Amanda! I’m sending you a virtual slice of Ice Cream Milky Way Brownie Pie! Happy Birthday!!!

      Reply

  12. This Brownie Pie looks really delicious! Love it! We dont have milky way candy here in Spain but I´m sure I can replace it with something similar.. Xx

    Reply

    1. Ahhhh, no Milky Way!?! But yeah, you could use whatever is your favorite candy instead 🙂

      Reply

  18. this is my new go to birthday cake. I’ve loved ice cream cake since forever and add brownie and milkyway’s another favorite….OMG

    Reply

    1. I’m so happy to hear that, Monica! I love ice cream cakes too!

      Reply

  19. Looks so good! I’ve never made a brownie ice cream cake before. Is the brownie and Milky Way candy hard from being in freezer overnight? How long do you recommend leaving out before serving? Thanks!

    Reply

    1. Thanks Vicki! I leave it out for about 10 minutes before slicing. The brownies aren’t too hard. The candy can get a little hard, so I recommend chopping into small pieces to keep them from being rock solid. Enjoy!

      Reply

  20. Have you ever made this recipe using a boxed brownie mix?
    Would this work to save time?
    Thanks!

    Reply

    1. Hi Laura. I have not tried this recipe with a boxed mix. I’m sure it would work fine. The cooking time may vary.

      Reply

  21. I made this for Easter dessert and it was extra scrumptious. Definitely filing this recipe away for later. Thank you for sharing!

    Reply

  22. YUM 🙂 I am including this recipe and link in my new post this week for a Milky Way Cupcake recipe- and wanted to include some more delicious Milky Way recipes from around the big ol’ web! And had to include this one for sure!

    Reply